Ashley G.

"Amazing food!!! Everything is perfect everytime we come. Great brisket and burgers. Place is very cozy and not too loud so you can easily talk. Comfy booths and a very nice bar with a huge selection. Luke is a great server very friendly and attentive the restaurant is lucky to have him. Queso burger, thanksgiving gobbler sandwich, scallops were all FANTASTIC."

Brad O.

"Super delicious BBQ brought to you by the masterminds of Hindsight BBQ!!! This place rocks and the whole experience is great. The star of course is the food, which is dynamite. Definitely recommend the BBQ Brisket plate, which melts in your mouth. The potato salad side was tasty, and the cornbread was out of this world (smothered in maple butter). Server was super nice too. Highly recommend!"

Sarah

"Amazed by Cowboy Butter! Excellent food and excellent service. I’m a somewhat picky local who enjoys down to earth atmospheres with great service and excellent food quality (hopefully 🤞 but ok with food being just ok if the service is good). Pleasantly surprised to say the food is GREAT. Anytime I have eaten here the food and service were awesome. Highly recommend."

Chris M

"We had the brisket, the short rib, and baby back ribs,,, AFTER we started with the wings and the burnt tips. This was absolutely some of the barbecue I've ever had. The wait-staff and manager were perfectly attentive and happy to guide us through our orders- from their craft beer, appetizers, entrées, sides and desserts. Every one of us agreed, there wasn't a thing brought to our table that wasn't the best example of great barbecue restaurant."

Erin S.

"I have visited this restaurant several times including during their soft open and thankfully have never had a negative experience. The food is some of the best barbecue I’ve had in the area- the baby back ribs, pulled pork baked potato, and Mac and cheese are some major highlights. The queso and cornbread are unmatched and we make sure to get enough for everyone every time we visit. If you haven’t tried them, what are you doing?? Change that as soon as you can. The prices may seem high but are on par for other barbecue in the area; you get what you pay for and more. As natives of new Milford we have seen many restaurants come and go on bank street, and Cowboy Butter is a welcome addition that we hope will be here for us to frequent for years to come."

Kristin B.

"It’s been a long time since I’ve enjoyed the taste of my food this much. Every dish was flavorful, fresh, and prepared with care. The quality truly stood out, and the taste was well worth the price. The vibe was warm and cozy, and the service was friendly and prompt. A wonderful dining experience—I’ll definitely be returning."